Skip to content

Implement comprehensive SOLID principles architecture for Hub Priorit…#6

Open
oh-da wants to merge 1 commit intomainfrom
claude/solid-principles-implementation-013di3QBDmkdiJ5vT1CXxxay
Open

Implement comprehensive SOLID principles architecture for Hub Priorit…#6
oh-da wants to merge 1 commit intomainfrom
claude/solid-principles-implementation-013di3QBDmkdiJ5vT1CXxxay

Conversation

@oh-da
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

@oh-da oh-da commented Nov 30, 2025

…ization Framework

This commit implements a complete SOLID-based architecture for the integrated transport hub prioritization system, demonstrating all five SOLID principles:

SINGLE RESPONSIBILITY PRINCIPLE (SRP):

  • Each class has one clear responsibility
  • Data loading, validation, scoring, classification separated
  • Examples: ActivityScorer (only scores activity), MinMaxNormalizer (only normalizes)

OPEN/CLOSED PRINCIPLE (OCP):

  • System open for extension, closed for modification
  • New scorers extend BaseScorer without modifying framework
  • New filters implement IEligibilityFilter
  • Factory pattern for data loaders allows registration of new types

LISKOV SUBSTITUTION PRINCIPLE (LSP):

  • All IScorer implementations are interchangeable
  • All INormalizer implementations are interchangeable
  • Repository implementations can be swapped
  • Contracts maintained across all implementations

INTERFACE SEGREGATION PRINCIPLE (ISP):

  • Small, focused interfaces (IScorer, INormalizer, IEligibilityFilter)
  • Clients depend only on methods they use
  • No fat interfaces forcing unnecessary dependencies

DEPENDENCY INVERSION PRINCIPLE (DIP):

  • High-level modules depend on abstractions
  • Scorers depend on INormalizer interface, not concrete normalizer
  • Services depend on IDataRepository, not concrete repository
  • Configuration injected via IConfiguration protocol

Key Components:

  • src/interfaces.py: Core interfaces and protocols
  • src/config.py: Configuration management with dependency injection
  • src/data/: Data layer (loaders, validators, repository)
  • src/spatial/: Spatial operations (H3, geometry) with DI
  • src/classification/: Hub classification (eligibility, hierarchy)
  • src/scoring/: Scoring system (5 criteria scorers, normalization, aggregation)
  • tests/test_solid_principles.py: Comprehensive tests demonstrating SOLID

Architecture Patterns Used:

  • Template Method: BaseScorer defines workflow
  • Strategy Pattern: Interchangeable scorers, normalizers, classifiers
  • Composite Pattern: CompositeEligibilityFilter
  • Repository Pattern: Data access abstraction
  • Factory Pattern: DataLoaderFactory

Documentation:

  • README.md: Project overview and usage
  • SOLID_PRINCIPLES.md: Detailed explanation of SOLID implementation
  • Comprehensive docstrings throughout

All code follows SOLID principles for maintainability, testability, extensibility, and clarity.

…ization Framework

This commit implements a complete SOLID-based architecture for the integrated
transport hub prioritization system, demonstrating all five SOLID principles:

SINGLE RESPONSIBILITY PRINCIPLE (SRP):
- Each class has one clear responsibility
- Data loading, validation, scoring, classification separated
- Examples: ActivityScorer (only scores activity), MinMaxNormalizer (only normalizes)

OPEN/CLOSED PRINCIPLE (OCP):
- System open for extension, closed for modification
- New scorers extend BaseScorer without modifying framework
- New filters implement IEligibilityFilter
- Factory pattern for data loaders allows registration of new types

LISKOV SUBSTITUTION PRINCIPLE (LSP):
- All IScorer implementations are interchangeable
- All INormalizer implementations are interchangeable
- Repository implementations can be swapped
- Contracts maintained across all implementations

INTERFACE SEGREGATION PRINCIPLE (ISP):
- Small, focused interfaces (IScorer, INormalizer, IEligibilityFilter)
- Clients depend only on methods they use
- No fat interfaces forcing unnecessary dependencies

DEPENDENCY INVERSION PRINCIPLE (DIP):
- High-level modules depend on abstractions
- Scorers depend on INormalizer interface, not concrete normalizer
- Services depend on IDataRepository, not concrete repository
- Configuration injected via IConfiguration protocol

Key Components:
- src/interfaces.py: Core interfaces and protocols
- src/config.py: Configuration management with dependency injection
- src/data/: Data layer (loaders, validators, repository)
- src/spatial/: Spatial operations (H3, geometry) with DI
- src/classification/: Hub classification (eligibility, hierarchy)
- src/scoring/: Scoring system (5 criteria scorers, normalization, aggregation)
- tests/test_solid_principles.py: Comprehensive tests demonstrating SOLID

Architecture Patterns Used:
- Template Method: BaseScorer defines workflow
- Strategy Pattern: Interchangeable scorers, normalizers, classifiers
- Composite Pattern: CompositeEligibilityFilter
- Repository Pattern: Data access abstraction
- Factory Pattern: DataLoaderFactory

Documentation:
- README.md: Project overview and usage
- SOLID_PRINCIPLES.md: Detailed explanation of SOLID implementation
- Comprehensive docstrings throughout

All code follows SOLID principles for maintainability, testability,
extensibility, and clarity.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants