diff --git a/specifyweb/backend/stored_queries/batch_edit.py b/specifyweb/backend/stored_queries/batch_edit.py
index 56f3fedfaed..7798f14d197 100644
--- a/specifyweb/backend/stored_queries/batch_edit.py
+++ b/specifyweb/backend/stored_queries/batch_edit.py
@@ -1095,7 +1095,20 @@ def _get_orig_column(string_id: str):
 
     # We would have arbitarily sorted the columns, so our columns will not be correct.
     # Rather than sifting the data, we just add a default visual order.
-    visual_order = Func.first(headers_enumerated)
+    visual_order_groups: list[list[int]] = [[] for _ in visible_fields]
+    for index, (key, _header) in headers_enumerated:
+        # Find the column's original position if it existed in the origin query
+        original_place = key[0]
+        duplicate_index = key[1]
+        if original_place < len(visible_fields):
+            visual_order_groups[original_place].insert(duplicate_index, index)
+        else:
+            # New field/column. Add it to the end of the dataset.
+            visual_order_groups.append([index])
+
+    visual_order: list[int] = []
+    for bucket in visual_order_groups:
+        visual_order.extend(bucket)
 
     headers = Func.second(key_and_headers)
 
diff --git a/specifyweb/backend/stored_queries/tests/test_batch_edit.py b/specifyweb/backend/stored_queries/tests/test_batch_edit.py
index 6372521c6f3..307670a294f 100644
--- a/specifyweb/backend/stored_queries/tests/test_batch_edit.py
+++ b/specifyweb/backend/stored_queries/tests/test_batch_edit.py
@@ -155,9 +155,9 @@ def test_basic_run(self):
                 "CollectionObject catalogNumber",
                 "CollectionObject integer1",
                 "Agent (formatted)",
-                "CollectingEvent (formatted)",
                 "Agent firstName",
                 "Agent lastName",
+                "CollectingEvent (formatted)",
                 "Locality localityName",
             ],
         )
@@ -554,6 +554,14 @@ def test_duplicates_flattened(self):
                 "CollectionObject catalogNumber",
                 "CollectionObject integer1",
                 "Agent (formatted)",
+                "Determination integer1",
+                "Determination integer1 #2",
+                "Determination integer1 #3",
+                "Determination remarks",
+                "Determination remarks #2",
+                "Determination remarks #3",
+                "Preparation countAmt",
+                "Preparation text1",
                 "Agent firstName",
                 "Agent lastName",
                 "AgentSpecialty specialtyName",
@@ -561,29 +569,21 @@ def test_duplicates_flattened(self):
                 "AgentSpecialty specialtyName #3",
                 "AgentSpecialty specialtyName #4",
                 "Collector remarks",
-                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber",
                 "Collector remarks #2",
-                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #2",
                 "Collector remarks #3",
-                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #3",
                 "Collector remarks #4",
-                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #4",
                 "Collector remarks #5",
-                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #5",
                 "Collector remarks #6",
-                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #6",
                 "Collector remarks #7",
-                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #7",
                 "Collector remarks #8",
-                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #8",
-                "Determination integer1",
-                "Determination remarks",
-                "Determination integer1 #2",
-                "Determination remarks #2",
-                "Determination integer1 #3",
-                "Determination remarks #3",
-                "Preparation countAmt",
-                "Preparation text1"
+                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber",
+                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #2",
+                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #3",
+                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #4",
+                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #5",
+                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #6",
+                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #7",
+                "CollectingEvent stationFieldNumber #8"
             ],
         )