Insufficient funds for gas * price + value"}, method="sendTransaction", transaction=undefined, code=INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS

[phil3k3]

✅ Prerequisites

• Did you perform a cursory search of open issues? Is this bug already reported elsewhere?
• Are you running the latest SDK version?
• Are you reporting to the correct repository (magic-sdk)?

🐛 Description

I am receiving INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS when trying to use the signer of Magic's RPC provider.

Magic RPC Error: [-32603] Error forwarded from node: insufficient funds for gas * price + value"}, method="sendTransaction", transaction=undefined, code=INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS

🧩 Steps to Reproduce

1. Create sample project as described in https://magic.link/docs/dedicated/login-methods/email/integration/web
2. Generate a Web3Provider using ethers v5
   const owner = new ethers.providers.Web3Provider(magic.rpcProvider as any);
3. Use the signer of this provider to retrieve the balance of an ERC 20 token

const contract = new ethers.Contract(tokenAddress, erc20Abi, owner.getSigner());
const balance = await contract.balanceOf(receiver);

🤔 Expected behavior

Getting the balance of this usually gas-less transaction.

😮 Actual behavior

"Magic RPC Error: [-32603] Error forwarded from node: insufficient funds for gas * price + value"}, method="sendTransaction", transaction=undefined, code=INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS

💻 Code Sample

[If possible, please provide a code repository, gist, code snippet or sample files to reproduce the issue.]

🌎 Environment

Software	Version(s)
magic-sdk	21.0.0
Browser	Chrome
yarn	1.22.19
Operating System	MacOS 13.4.1

[am-hernandez]

Hello @phil3k3 ,

The error you shared should throw when you attempt to send a transaction or interact with a smart contract but don't have enough native token balance to cover the cost of the interaction. It should not throw for a contract interaction that is just reading state, because there is no fee for reading the contract state.

Would you be able to provide a reproducible code sandbox where this issue is reproduced? If not, do you have steps for us to follow to reproduce this issue?

I created a sandbox here that makes a call to the Uniswap contract to get the balance of an account. The call properly returns even with a new user wallet because balanceOf is a view function and does not require gas. You may fork the demo to reproduce your issue.

Thank you,

[JosephLeva]

@phil3k3 did you ever find a way to send a transaction with gas using a magic wallet account? I am currently receiving the same error.