Requirement Checker fails with Extension conflict

[llaville]

Bug report

Question	Answer
Box version	4.6.10
PHP version	8.2.30
Platform with version	Ubuntu 24.04 LTS on Docker and WSL2
Github Repo	none source are required for this issue

Description

The requirement checker (https://github.com/box-project/box/blob/4.6.10/src/RequirementChecker/RequirementsBuilder.php#L94-L101)
did not take care to compare extension constraint and version available.

Context

Conflict between symfony/cache and redis PHP extension is only for version lower than 6.1 :

• https://github.com/symfony/cache/blob/7.4/composer.json#L46

And I got version redis 6.3 installed

container  [Docker] > php --re redis | grep "redis version"
Extension [ <persistent> extension #71 redis version 6.3.0 ] {

If you extract (with BOX 4.6.10 extract command) the https://github.com/overtrue/phplint/releases/download/9.7.1/phplint.phar copy
and check into vendor/composer/installed.php file, you will see this chunk of content

        'symfony/cache' => array(
            'pretty_version' => 'v7.4.0',
            'version' => '7.4.0.0',
            'reference' => 'a7a1325a5de2e54ddb45fda002ff528162e48293',
            'type' => 'library',
            'install_path' => __DIR__ . '/../symfony/cache',
            'aliases' => array(),
            'dev_requirement' => false,
        ),

Expected results

container  [Docker] > ./phplint.phar --version
phplint 9.7.1@69ec670

Actual results

container  [Docker] > ./phplint.phar --version

Box Requirements Checker
========================

> Using PHP 8.2.30
> PHP is not using any php.ini file.

> Checking Box requirements:
  ......E.


 [ERROR] Your system is not ready to run the application.


Fix the following mandatory requirements:
=========================================

 * The package "symfony/cache" conflicts with the extension "redis". You need to disable it in order to run this application.

Workaround

Tip

Skip the requirement checker

• https://box-project.github.io/box/requirement-checker/#skipping-the-requirement-checker

container  [Docker] > BOX_REQUIREMENT_CHECKER=0 ./phplint.phar --version
phplint 9.7.1@69ec670